Implications Of The Abolition Of The Presidential Threshold For The Realization Of Substantial Democracy
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32801/.v10i1.197Keywords:
Presidential Threshold, Substantial Democracy, Political Representation, Electoral Inclusivity, Political StabilityAbstract
The implementation of the presidential threshold (PT) in Indonesia’s electoral system has been a significant topic of debate in national politics. PT, which requires political parties or coalitions to meet a certain vote threshold to nominate a presidential candidate, is considered an instrument to strengthen political stability. However, critics argue that PT limits voter choice, benefits major parties, and hinders the realization of a more substantial democracy. This article aims to analyze the implications of abolishing PT for achieving substantial democracy, which emphasizes openness, broad participation, and equality in the political process. The findings of this discussion indicate that the implementation of PT in Indonesia restricts political representation, marginalizes small parties and independent candidates, and reduces voter choice diversity. Although PT aims to strengthen political stability by encouraging coalitions, it risks undermining inclusive democracy. The varying number of presidential candidates in 2004 (5 candidates), 2009 and 2024 (3 candidates), as well as 2014 and 2019 (2 candidates), demonstrates PT’s impact on political competition. More candidates provide greater choices but can fragment votes, whereas fewer candidates simplify elections but reduce inclusivity. Abolishing PT could create opportunities for more candidates, fostering a more inclusive and competitive environment, but it may also lead to political fragmentation and difficulties in coalition formation. Therefore, a balanced reform between inclusivity and political stability is necessary to enhance the quality of democracy in Indonesia.
References
Ahmad, Nyarwi. “The Four Faces of Authoritarian Populism and Their Consequences on Journalistic Freedom: A Lesson Learnt From Indonesia’s 2019 Presidential Election.” Trans Trans -Regional and -National Studies of Southeast Asia, 2021. doi:10.1017/trn.2021.16.
Al-Hamdi, Ridho, Tanto Lailam, and Sakir. “The Presidential Threshold Design in Indonesia’s Electoral System: In Search of ‘Win-Win Situation’ Among Unfinished Debates,” 2021. doi:10.2991/assehr.k.211227.050.
Alfani, Hendra, Agustinus Rustanta, Elsie Oktivera, and Steffi Lee. “Media Framing Against Identity Political Orientation as a Representation of Political Interests Ahead of the 2024 Presidential Election.” Kne Social Sciences, 2023. doi:10.18502/kss.v8i12.13685.
Anggreani, Shifa. “Presidential Threshold Constitutionality Dilemma in Indonesia: A Comparative Study With Brazil.” Unisia, 2024. doi:10.20885/unisia.vol42.iss1.art18.
Anjarsari, Lulu. “Presidential Threshold Bertentangan Dengan Konstitusi.” Jakarta: Mahkamah Konstitusi, 2024. https://www.mkri.id/index.php?page=web.Berita&id=21997.
Anugerah, Boy. “Strengthening Democracy in Indonesia: Comparison Between Representative and Direct Presidential Election Policies.” Jurnal Studi Sosial Dan Politik, 2022. doi:10.19109/jssp.v6i1.10650.
Arslantaş, Düzgün, Şenol Arslantaş, and André Kaiser. “Does the Electoral System Foster a Predominant Party System? Evidence from Turkey.” Swiss Political Science Review 26, no. 1 (2020): 125–43. doi:10.1111/spsr.12386.
Bannikova, Marina, Artyom Jelnov, and Pavel Jelnov. “The Number of Parties and Decision-Making in Legislatures.” Games 12, no. 4 (2021): 1–10. doi:10.3390/g12040076.
Bayer, М, Felix S Bethke, and Daniel Lambach. “The Democratic Dividend of Nonviolent Resistance.” Journal of Peace Research, 2016. doi:10.1177/0022343316658090.
Bethke, Felix S, and Jonathan Pinckney. “Non-Violent Resistance and the Quality of Democracy.” Conflict Management and Peace Science, 2019. doi:10.1177/0738894219855918.
Boese, Vanessa A, and Matthew Charles Wilson. “A Short History of Contestation and Participation.” SSRN Electronic Journal, 2022. doi:10.2139/ssrn.4022448.
Borges, André. Razões Da Fragmentação: Coligações e Estratégias Partidárias Na Presença de Eleições Majoritárias e Proporcionais Simultâneas. Dados. Vol. 62, 2019. doi:10.1590/001152582019179.
Bucur, Cristina, and José Antônio Cheibub. “Presidential Partisanship in Government Formation: Do Presidents Favor Their Parties When They Appoint the Prime Minister?” Political Research Quarterly, 2017. doi:10.1177/1065912917716334.
Chapman, Hannah S, Margaret Hanson, Valery Dzutsati, and Paul DeBell. “Under the Veil of Democracy: What Do People Mean When They Say They Support Democracy?” Perspectives on Politics, 2023. doi:10.1017/s1537592722004157.
Cheeseman, Nic. “Kenya’s 2017 Elections: Winner-Takes-All Politics as Useal?” Jurnal of Eastern African Studis 13, no. 2 (2019).
Dacombe, Rod, and Phil Parvin. “Participatory Democracy in an Age of Inequality.” Representation, 2021. doi:10.1080/00344893.2021.1933151.
Deckman, Melissa, and Jared McDonald. “Uninspired by Old White Guys: The Mobilizing Factor of Younger, More Diverse Candidates for Gen Z Women.” Politics & Gender, 2022. doi:10.1017/s1743923x21000477.
Dian Sabrina, Muhammad Saad. “Keadilan Dalam Pemilu Bedasarkan Sistem Presidensial Threshold.” Widya Pranata Hukum Jurnal Kajian Dan Penelitian Hukum, 2021. doi:10.37631/widyapranata.v3i1.268.
Diantha, I Made Pasek, Ni Ketut Supasti Dharmawan, and I Gede Artha. Metode Penelitian Hukum Dan Penulisan Disertasi. 1st ed. Denpasar: Swasta Nulus, 2018.
Elsässer, Lea, and Armin Schäfer. “Political Inequality in Rich Democracies.” Annual Review of Political Science 26 (2023): 469–87. doi:10.1146/annurev-polisci-052521-094617.
Fuqoha, Fuqoha. “Pengisian Jabatan Presiden Dan Presidential Threshold Dalam Demokrasi Konstitusional Di Indonesia.” Ajudikasi Jurnal Ilmu Hukum, 2018. doi:10.30656/ajudikasi.v1i2.495.
Ghoffar, Abdul. “Problematika Presidential Threshold: Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi Dan Pengalaman Di Negara Lain.” Jurnal Konstitusi, 2018. doi:10.31078/jk1532.
Grecu, Silviu Petru. “Using Nonlinear and Structural Equations (Sem) for Testing the Correlation Between Political Culture and Substantive Democracy. Cross-National Comparisons.” Journal of Intercultural Management and Ethics 6, no. 2 (2023). doi:10.35478/jime.2023.2.08.
Hakim, Dani Amran. “Questioning Presidential Threshold in Indonesia: Constitutional Analysis and Democracy Implementation.” Veteran Law Review, 2024. doi:10.35586/velrev.v7i1.7591.
Hall, Andrew B, and Daniel M Thompson. “Who Punishes Extremist Nominees? Candidate Ideology and Turning Out the Base in US Elections.” American Political Science Review, 2018. doi:10.1017/s0003055418000023.
Haruni, Catur Wido. “Presidential Threshold in the Presidential Election From the Perspective of Constitutional Democracy and State of Law.” Kne Social Sciences, 2022. doi:10.18502/kss.v7i15.12112.
Haruni, Catur Wido, M Khoidin, Widodo Ekatjahyana, and Aries Harianto. “Proportionality of the Regional Representative Council in Legislative Function,” 2020. doi:10.2991/aebmr.k.200226.036.
Hidayaturrahman, Mohammad, Bonaventura Ngarawula, and Kridawati Sadhana. “Political Investors: Political Elite Oligarchy and Mastery of Regional Resources in Indonesia.” Asian Journal of Comparative Politics, 2020. doi:10.1177/2057891120917213.
Hiller, Tobias. “Measuring the Difficulties in Forming a Coalition Government.” Games 14, no. 2 (2023). doi:10.3390/g14020032.
Istiqoh, Akhdiva Elfi, Zuly Qodir, and Zakly Hanafi Ahmad. “Narrative Policy Framework: Presidential Threshold Policy Toward the 2024 Election.” Jurnal Bina Praja, 2022. doi:10.21787/jbp.14.2022.505-516.
Kadivar, Mohammad Ali, Adaner Usmani, and Benjamin H Bradlow. “The Long March: Deep Democracy in Cross-National Perspective.” Social Forces, 2019. doi:10.1093/sf/soz050.
Kaul, Volker. “Sources of Democracy: Rights, Trust and Solidarity.” Philosophy & Social Criticism, 2020. doi:10.1177/0191453720921975.
Lee, Hyo Won, and Sijeong Lim. “Making Sense of Citizen Desire for IO Democracy: An Analysis of Public Opinion Across 44 Countries.” European Journal of International Relations, 2022. doi:10.1177/13540661221091361.
Lührmann, Anna, Staffan I Lindberg, and Marcus Tannenberg. “Regimes in the World (RIW): A Robust Regime Type Measure Based on v-Dem.” SSRN Electronic Journal, 2017. doi:10.2139/ssrn.2971869.
Maulana Rahman, Mohammad Akbar. “Indonesia’s Presidential Threshold: An Analysis of Legal and Political Dynamics.” Jurnal Mengkaji Indonesia, 2023. doi:10.59066/jmi.v2i2.401.
Monteiro, Josef M. “Presidential Threshold and Parliamentary Threshold Setting in Elections.” Journal of Progressive Law and Legal Studies, 2023. doi:10.59653/jplls.v1i02.32.
Muslimin, J M, Ahmad Fadoliy, and Wildan Munawar. “Law and Politics: Study of the Presidential Threshold in the 2019 General Election of Indonesia.” Politicon Jurnal Ilmu Politik, 2021. doi:10.15575/politicon.v3i1.11523.
Nilsson, Jan. “Towards a New Taxonomy of Democracy,” 2023. doi:10.33774/coe-2023-jd8ll.
Nugroho, Rahmat Muhajir, Sudarsono, Istislam Istislam, and Muchamad Ali Safa’at. “Comparison of Threshold Provisions for Presidential Candidacy in Indonesia and Turkey,” 2022. doi:10.2991/978-2-494069-65-7_4.
Nyhan, Brendan, Gretchen Helmke, Mitchell Sanders, Katherine Clayton, John Carey, and Susan C Stokes. “Who Will Defend Democracy? Evaluating Tradeoffs in Candidate Support Among Partisan Donors and Voters,” 2020. doi:10.33774/apsa-2019-wjva3-v5.
Omodia, S M. “Political Parties and National Integration in Emerging Democracies: A Focus on the Nigerian State.” Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, 2018. doi:10.2478/mjss-2018-0162.
Parvin, Phil. “The Participatory Paradox: An Egalitarian Critique of Participatory Democracy.” Representation 57, no. 2 (2021): 263–85. doi:10.1080/00344893.2020.1823461.
Permanasari, Eka, Sahid Mochtar, and Rahma Purisari. “Political Representation in Urban Public Space in Jakarta Child-Friendly Public Space (Ruang Publik Terpadu Ramah Anak – RPTRA).” International Journal of Built Environment and Sustainability, 2019. doi:10.11113/ijbes.v6.n2.351.
Rannie, Mahesa, Retno Saraswati, and Fifiana Wisnaeni. “Does the Reform of the Parliamentary and Presidential Threshold Strengthen the Presidential System in Indonesia?” Sriwijaya Law Review 8, no. 1 (2024): 133–51. doi:10.28946/slrev.Vol8.Iss1.3157.pp133-151.
Ridho, M Zainor. “The Constitutionality of the Presidential Threshold on the 2019 Election in Indonesia: An Analysis on Constitutional Court Decision 72/Puu-Xv/2017.” Asy-Syir Ah Jurnal Ilmu Syari Ah Dan Hukum, 2020. doi:10.14421/ajish.v54i2.916.
Rifky, Imam Pratama. “The Legitimacy of Presidential Threshold Towards Indonesian Citizens’ Democracy and Constitutional Rights.” Constitutionale, 2021. doi:10.25041/constitutionale.v2i2.2445.
Rivera-Batiz, Francisco L. “Democracy, Governance, and Economic Growth: Theory and Evidence,” 2018. doi:10.1142/9789813209398_0008.
Robinson, Darrel, and Marcus Österman. “Educating Democrats or Autocrats? The Regime-Conditional Effect of Education on Support for Democracy.” Political Studies, 2022. doi:10.1177/00323217211067385.
Rojon, Sebastien, Arieke J Rijken, and Bert Klandermans. “A Survey Experiment on Citizens’ Preferences for ‘Vote–Centric’ vs. ‘Talk–Centric’ Democratic Innovations With Advisory vs. Binding Outcomes.” Politics and Governance, 2019. doi:10.17645/pag.v7i2.1900.
Ryan, Josh M. “Partisan Dynamics in Presidential Primaries and Campaign Divisiveness.” American Politics Research, 2017. doi:10.1177/1532673x17738278.
Sabirin, Ahmad. “Civil and Political Rights in Constitutionality of Accommodation of Individual Candidates and Elimination of Presidential Thresholds From the Perspective of the 1945 Constitution.” International Journal of Law and Public Policy, 2023. doi:10.36079/lamintang.ijlapp-0502.499.
Sabrina, Dian Fitri, and Brett Inder. “Concentration of Power in Nomination of Presidential Candidates in Indonesia.” Asian Journal of Comparative Politics 9, no. 3 (2023): 375–87. doi:10.1177/20578911231199530.
Santoso Gobel, Rahmat Teguh. “Rekonseptualisasi Ambang Batas Pencalonan Presiden Dan Wakil Presiden (Presidential Threshold) Dalam Pemilu Serentak.” Jambura Law Review, 2019. doi:10.33756/jalrev.v1i1.1987.
Saputra, Febrian Vivaldi. “Dampak Presidential Threshold Terhadap Hasil Pemilihan Presiden Pada Rangkaian Acara Pemilu Menurut Pandangan Mahasiswa.” Jurnal Ilmiah Mimbar Demokrasi, 2023. doi:10.21009/jimd.v22i2.31774.
Savage, Lee. “How and When Do Presidents Influence the Duration of Coalition Bargaining in Semi‐presidential Systems?” European Journal of Political Research, 2017. doi:10.1111/1475-6765.12227.
Setiawan, Adjie Hari. “Politik Hukum Presidential Threshold 20% Dalam Undang-Undang Nomor 7 Tahun 2017.” Jurnal Asosiasi Pengajar Hukum Tata Negara Hukum Administrasi Negara (Japhtn-Han), 2023. doi:10.55292/japhtnhan.v2i1.64.
Setiawan, Angga Eka. “Understanding Indonesia’s Presidential Threshold: A Study on Political Rights.” Jurnal Mengkaji Indonesia, 2024. doi:10.59066/jmi.v3i1.622.
Shapira, Reuven. “Preventing Leaders’ Autocratic Entrenchment by Exponential Super-Majority Threshold Escalators.” Frontiers in Political Science 5, no. November 2018 (2023). doi:10.3389/fpos.2023.1173646.
Sidiq Wisnaeni, Muh. As. “Democratic Principles-Based Reconstruction of Presidential Threshold Provisions on Indonesian Presidential Elections.” International Journal of Social Science and Human Research, 2022. doi:10.47191/ijsshr/v5-i2-24.
Sigman, Rachel, and Staffan I Lindberg. “Democracy for All: Conceptualizing and Measuring Egalitarian Democracy.” Political Science Research and Methods 7, no. 3 (2019): 595–612. doi:10.1017/psrm.2018.6.
Skaaning Frederiksen, Kristian Vrede. “Do Two-Party Systems Hamper Defection From Undemocratic Candidates?,” 2022. doi:10.31219/osf.io/wmzj3.
Stokke, Kristian. “Democratization in the Global South: From Democratic Transitions to Transformative Democratic Politics.” Geography Compass, 2018. doi:10.1111/gec3.12412.
Torfing, Jacob, and Christopher Ansell. “Strengthening Political Leadership and Policy Innovation through the Expansion of Collaborative Forms of Governance.” Public Management Review 19, no. 1 (2017): 37–54. doi:10.1080/14719037.2016.1200662.
Touchton, Michael, Stephanie McNulty, and Brian Wampler. “Participatory Budgeting and Community Development: A Global Perspective.” American Behavioral Scientist, 2022. doi:10.1177/00027642221086957.
Trantidis, Aris. “Is Government Contestability an Integral Part of the Definition of Democracy?” Politics, 2016. doi:10.1177/0263395715619635.
Wiraguna, Sidi Ahyar, and Zudan Arief Fakrulloh. “Legal Reforms in Indonesia Related to ‘Presidential Threshold’ of Presidential Candidate in Law No. 7/2017 Concerning General Elections.” Journal of Law Theory and Law Enforcement, 2023. doi:10.56943/jlte.v2i2.194.
Wutoy, Maichel, Eliyunus Waruwu, Ayler Beniah Ndraha, and Alwi Al Hadad. “Application of the Presidential Threshold Concept in the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election System and Its Impact on the Indonesian Constitutional System.” Journal of Digitainability Realism & Mastery (Dream), 2022. doi:10.56982/journalo.v1i03.28.
Section Policies
